Skip to main content

It Isn’t Fair!

 This is the sermon I preached Sunday at St. Timothy Lutheran Church. The gospel was Matthew 20:1-16

“It’s not fair!” How many of you, who are parents, aunts and uncles, anyone who has had anything to do with children, have heard these words. Our goal is to explain to the child why something can't be done. That may help, or it may not.

God doesn’t play fair, at least by our standards. As we look at today’s difficult, startling parable, we may respond like the early workers, like children. Maybe we are those called later in the day, who embraced faith later in life. 

There are two main parts of this parable: the hiring of the workers and then the paying of the workers. From the beginning, just the way the parable plays out lets us know that something is up. 

For one thing, it would be unusual for a landowner himself to go hire workers. Why didn’t he send someone else? Throughout the day, he goes four times to hire workers. Palestinian workers in Palestine go to specific places to wait to work for Israeli bosses to pick them up from the labor pool. 

The landowner goes early at about 6 am. Then he goes at 9, noon and finally 5 pm. This too tells us that we are dealing with unusual practices. Who would hire workers with only one hour left in the workday? Just one note about his meeting with the last group at 5 pm. Our translation says, “Why are you standing here idle all day?” It makes them sound lazy, like they were just wasting time. A better translation of “standing idle” is literally “without work.” Now that’s different! It has a better connotation of “wanting work, but not able to find it” (Amy-Jill Levine, Short Stories By Jesus). 

Next we get to paying the workers. And here it really looks like God is not being fair. Everyone was paid the same, exactly what the landowner promised: the “usual daily wage” or “whatever is right.” So far, so good. However, Jesus could have avoided any controversy if he told the parable differently. If those hired first were paid first, there would be no problem. 

What is the parable really about? On the surface, it appears to be about wealth, but the underlying issue is about status in the reign of heaven. It seems to be about wages, but something else must be going on. I love the ending of the parable. “Am I not allowed to do what I choose with what belongs to me? Or are you envious because I am generous?” (V. 15). 

God doesn’t play fair. Author Mary Gordon, in her book Reading Jesus, answers God’s question with painful honesty…Yes, “I am envious because you are generous.  I am envious because my work has not been rewarded.  I am envious because someone has gotten away with something.  Envy has eaten out my heart.”

I appreciate Gordon’s candor, because really, if this parable doesn’t offend us at least a little, then we’re not paying attention.  After all, we know what fairness is, and we know how it’s supposed to play out. Equal pay for equal work is fair.  Equal pay for unequal work is NOT fair.  Having our sincere efforts noticed and praised is fair.  Having them ignored is NOT fair.  Rewarding hard work and ambition is fair.  Excusing sloth and sloppiness is NOT fair (Patrick J. Wilson, Feasting On the Gospels: Matthew, Volume 2).

The vineyard is symbolic of God’s reign in scripture. The first group entered and worked in the vineyard longer than those who came late. They had the blessing of being in God’s vineyard longer than all the others. 

What about those who came later, especially the ones who only worked an hour? Their pay must have blown them away. That’s the thing about God. God’s generosity is beyond anything we can imagine. That’s what bothered Jonah so much in our first lesson. He knew God would be gracious and would forgive the people of Nineveh. That would make him look foolish after preaching that God would destroy them. 

God is not interested in favoring the best, the biggest, the brightest — those with the elite educations, astonishing professional achievements and the fanciest houses and cars. God favors the disadvantaged. The first have to wait at the back of the line to get paid. The back of the line offers perspective (Wilson).

God can do what God wants to with what belongs to him. Do we envy God’s generosity to others? Let’s look at life through this parable and its final words, “So the last will be first, and the first will be last” (v. 15). 

Have you ever felt so dejected and down in the dumps when looking at what others have accomplished or what they have? What am I, chopped liver? In all situations, let our generous Lord lift you up, hold you and lead you. Then we can be a light for others. In this parable, Jesus illustrates that we are his so that we may leave our lives in God’s hands because they are not our own. As the Apostle Paul wrote, “What no eye has seen, nor ear heard, nor the human heart conceived, what God has prepared for those who love him” (1 Cor. 2:9). 



Popular posts from this blog

Bidden or Not Bidden...

My son and his fiancée were determined to have a secular wedding ceremony in Las Vegas. The phrase that kept going through my mind was, "Bidden or not bidden, God is present." God is with us whether we realize it or not. And of course we kept praying for them. They are a wonderful couple who are very good for each other. We are thrilled to have Marisa in our family. The setting was beautiful: an outdoor patio area with plants around. It was evening and there was a nice breeze. The groom's father and best man told us that when they met with the minister (yes, minister, not justice of the peace) they found out he's a Lutheran minister. Hmm, isn't that interesting? The ceremony used the traditional vows. The minister spoke seriously to Christian and Marisa, charging them that they were in this for the long long as they lived. He did not use the word God , but certainly gave them godly counsel in the ceremony. God was there...bidden or not bidden. God was th

Dancing with the Trinity

This is the sermon I preached at St. Timothy Lutheran Church on Trinity Sunday, 6/16/19. The text was John 16:12-15. This is Holy Trinity Sunday. What comes to mind when you think of the Trinity—questions, confusion, a puzzle, a mystery? It seems to me that just when you think you have a bit of understanding, it all starts to unravel as you think of something else. This is a difficult concept to wrap our minds around. For centuries, the early church struggled with a right and proper interpretation and understanding as they formulated the doctrine of the Trinity. The more I read, the more I see the wisdom of Dr. Jerry Christianson who taught The Early Church and its Creeds my first year of seminary. He explained the Trinity as a love relationship between the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Just as God is all about relationship, so too the Christian life is all about relationship: our relationship with God, our relationship with each other and our relationship with our community.

Specialty of the Day--Markan Sandwich

Below is the sermon I preached on Sunday, June 7 at St. Timothy Lutheran Church and St. Mark Lutheran Church. The gospel text is Mark 3:20-35 . Do you like sandwiches? What is your favorite kind? Is it peanut butter and jelly, roast beef, a meatball sub or maybe it's beef on wick. We know that a sandwich usually consists of two slices of bread with something in between them. Believe it or not, today's gospel also has a sandwich. It is a literary sandwich. This literary device is used by Mark in trying to explain a sub theme within a theme. Some scholars call this literary device, the Markan Sandwich. The Markan Sandwich begins with a story. Once you are really drawn into the story, Mark switches to another story. When that story is concluded, he switches back to the original story and finishes that.   The first slice of bread is Jesus' Nuclear family. People love to talk about the sensational and spread rumors, don't they? It was no different in Jesus