Skip to main content

It Isn't Fair

Yesterday I had the opportunity to preach at Bender's Lutheran Church. The scripture passage was Matthew 20:1-16. It has been over a year since I've had the opportunity to be with these folks. Here is the sermon:

            In this week’s gospel, Jesus is doing what he does best—turning everything upside down. Was there anything in the gospel that made you wonder—that puzzled you? I sure hope so. That is just what parables are supposed to do—catch us off guard—shock us—grab our attention.
            In this reading, the surprises start right out of the gate. I find it curious that the landowner is the one who goes out to look for workers for the field. He has a manager who works for him because he is the one who pays the workers at the end of the day. Why didn’t he have his manager do the hiring?
            The landowner hired day laborers to work for him. Those seeking work would gather in a central part of town to wait for someone to hire them. Unlike today, the work was just for that day. They had to go through this process every day. Day after day, these men would gather, hoping that someone would choose them so they could feed their families. We sometimes speak of living paycheck to paycheck, but they lived day to day. The “usual daily wage” (v. 2) was not a lot of money. It was less than minimum wage; it provided barely enough for their daily food.
            Apparently, the work was not done quickly enough, so the owner went out a second time to get more workers. He said he would pay them “whatever is right” (v. 2). That sounded good to them, so off they went to work with a sense of relief that perhaps they could feed their families that day.
            Now I am wondering if the landowner grossly underestimated how much work there was to do. He returns to the market area at noon and three for more laborers. That is late to get started working. At this time of year in the Holy Land, sunrise is before 6:30, which means you can get a nice early start. There are about 12 hours of daylight, so sunset occurs early as well. By the time the landowner hired the folks at three, they only had a few hours to work.
            However, he’s not done hiring. At five, with just a little over an hour of daylight remaining, he’s back out for more workers! The exchange between the boss and the potential employees is different this time. The boss asks, “'Why are you standing here idle all day?'” (Mat 20:6 NRS). Now that question is loaded with assumptions, isn’t it? Maybe with our Protestant work ethic, we would be asking the same thing. Are these people slackers? Did they sleep in? Maybe they had too much to drink last night and were hung over. Were they goofing off with their friends when they should have been working?
Do you remember team sports in gym class? For some of us, it was a humiliating time. The teacher would appoint team captains for each team. They would take turns choosing members for their teams. You would stand there waiting, hoping to be chosen. Perhaps like me, you were always picked last. You were there all right, waiting to begin, but you weren’t selected.
            The men weren’t working because no one chose them! Does that sound familiar?  Maybe some of you have lost your job since I was here last. You look and look, but no one hires you.
            The landowner had made numerous runs to the marketplace for more workers. Didn’t he see them? Were they invisible? There are those people that we just don’t notice or pay attention to. They can be people in our community living on the margins of society—without work, without a place to live, without hope. How do we invite them to come and work with us?
            Sometimes invisible people are members of our own church. Maybe they are newcomers. Their families were not charter members and they can’t recall generation after generation that has worshipped here. Who are the invisible people here? How do we see them as one of us and not an outsider? Do we even see them?
            Back to the parable… everyone is working together now, those who started at daylight and the newcomers. The work’s being done and all is well. Problems arise when it’s time to be paid. The owner has the manager start paying the people he hired last first. Doesn’t that seem somewhat odd? Why does he do this? And then he does something even stranger. The landowner pays the people who worked an hour a full day’s wage. Now of course when those hired earlier see that these people are paid the same amount that they were promised, so they naturally assume that they will receive more since they’ve been working longer. Wouldn’t you?
            When the first workers are paid, they are upset. It isn’t fair. They began to murmur and grumble and complain. In the Greek of the New Testament, they didn’t grumble just once and they were over it. The workers did this repeatedly. Now of course, the landowner wasn’t the one handing out the pay. He had his manager pay the men. The whole problem could have been avoided entirely if the landowner just had those who were the first to work be the first to be paid. Then they would have been on their way and no one would be the wiser.
            Do you think the landowner knew that? Why did he pay the last first? Did he want everyone to see what the latecomers got?  It certainly wasn’t fair!
            Fairness is not the point of this parable--grace and generosity are. Did the landowner really need to hire all those workers? Was the landowner seeing his position not only as an employer, but also as more of an obligation to take care of his fellow townspeople? We see the landowner searching and welcoming and extending generosity. Isn’t that just the way God pursues us--reaching out with grace, meeting our needs? God is not doing this alone. He is inviting us to help in this endeavor. In the slogan of the ELCA, “God’s work. Our hands,” God is calling us to meet the needs of one another. Are we using our time, talent, and treasures in a way that shows our thankfulness for what we have received to help those less fortunate? As we leave this church building today, let us keep our eyes open for those invisible people standing on the corner waiting for our invitation. Amen.

Google Image


Popular posts from this blog

If and If and If

This is the sermon I preached on Sunday, 10/1/17 at St. Timothy Lutheran Church and St. Mark Lutheran Church. The scripture text is Philippians 2:1-13

Paul’s letter to the Philippians is one of my favorites. It is full of positive, uplifting theology, like “RejoiceintheLordalways; again I will say, Rejoice (Phil. 4:4 ). It’s a feel-good kind of letter. Today’s passage from Philippians is chock full of great stuff and I could get at least 10 sermons out of

I'm Back & Giving Thanks

Sunday, 9/17, was my first Sunday back in the pulpit after 7 months. I am not completely healed from February's back surgery, but am mostly there. The doctor is letting me work only part time until our next visit. This is the sermon from Sunday, 9/17, preached at St. Timothy Lutheran Church and St. Mark Lutheran Church.  based on Psalm 103 1:-13.
When I read today’s lessons, I couldn’t take my eyes of of Psalm 103. This psalm is an individual psalm of one who was struggling in a desperate situation, who called out to God and God delivered him.This is my story too.
As most of you know, I had back surgery in Feb. and I too, received God’s deliverance. Following the back surgery, I contracted an Ecoli infection that nearly killed me. I am here today to declare with the psalmist: “Bless the Lord, O my soul, and all that is within me, bless his holy name. Bless the Lord, O my soul, and do not forget all his benefits…”
The odd thing about this psalm is that it isn’t a prayer. It is not ad…

Flying Rebukes

This is the sermon I preached on Sunday, 2/25/18 at St. Timothy. Lutheran Church. The text was Mark 8:31-38. 

Immediately before today’s gospel reading, Jesus had asked his disciples who people say that he is. This is where the light went on for Peter and he made the confession, “You are the Messiah” (Mark 8:29). Peter certainly gave the right answer and was likely thinking of the attributes given to whoever would be the Messiah. The Messiah, people thought, would deliver them from the crushing rule of the Romans. The Messiah would fight their enemies. Basically, the Messiah was a strong king-like figure.
But, now Jesus fleshes out for Peter and others what that is going to look like. They were completely unprepared for the reality.
“Jesus began to teach them” (v. 31). Hadn’t he been teaching the disciples all along? Maybe, but this was different. This wasn’t teaching about miracles and healing. This is the turning point in Mark’s gospel, marking a new beginning.
“Jesus began to teach the…